Composting Made Easy: How to Make Compost, Methods and Benefits

I really love compost and think everyone should learn to really love compost, too. If you have a homestead or garden and you aren’t composting, well then what the heck are you really doing with your time?! Even some HOA’s allow compost bins/piles. There’s almost no excuse, considering you can repurpose 20-50% of your kitchen waste through composting.


Well, according to Google:
com·post ˈkämˌpōst/ noun

  1. 1. decayed organic material used as a plant fertilizer.  

According to me:
GOLD. The most fun DIY project you’ll ever find! A perfect excuse to be outside. A way to give back to this beautiful plant we live on and reduce waste. Do you need any better reasons? Because I bet I could come up with more.


My relationship with compost started long before I ever owned a homestead and, I’ll admit, it wasn’t always a great relationship. It was one of those relationships where I thought I was giving 100% and thought Mr.Compost was only giving like 35%. It turned out that I just wasn’t being that good of a partner and I was not giving 100%. I was the problem (first step is admitting it!). The good news was that it was an easy fix once I read up on it, and now my relationship is hot, hot, hot. Literally!

I can’t put into words how excited I was when I pulled the stick out of my compost, grabbed it, and it was hot to the touch. Oh and just imagine the look on my face when I turn my compost on a chilly morning and it steams. Yes y’all! STEAMS because it’s so hot! Are you excited? Well, ya should be! We won’t cover all the different methods of composting, but I’ll tell you a bit about my compost history and how I started from the bottom, now I’m here.


When I first started composting, I was unintentionally cold composting. I didn’t know I was cold composting, but I knew my pile wasn’t getting hot and that made me hot! I’d get so frustrated. In my defense, throughout the beginning of my composting journey I thought the absolute only way to compost was to have a hot pile, and that just turned out to be false. I also didn’t know about nitrogen and carbon rich materials.

Cold composting is when you throw everything in a pile and wait a year or two until everything decomposes. Cold Compost = Slow Compost. Make sure you don’t put diseased plants or weed seeds in your cold compost pile because, since your pile won’t be heating up, they won’t be killed off. This is a fine, low-involvement method if you’re in no rush to use that beautiful, rich humus.  It is still a wonderful way to repurpose your kitchen scraps.


Vermicomposting is composting with worms. What?! Worms?! Yep, you got it. Worms are a part of the composting cycle no matter what method you use (except for the bokashi method). The vermicomposting method just utilizes a crucial part of the natural cycle.

***UPDATE 1/19/2018: Kevin from Epic Gardening reached out to me and shared a really spectacular, informal article he wrote on the Bokashi Method. I’d like to invite you all to read it HERE! It’s titled “Bokashi From Scratch: How To Build And Use Bokashi Composters“!***

When Emerson and I moved into our house we ordered some red wigglers and set up our DIY vermicomposting bin. It was so exciting to think these worms were going to turn our scraps into the soil – how cool! Unfortunately, we had no idea what we were doing, and all of our poor worms died. We didn’t keep them moist enough and weren’t consistently feeding them because all our scraps were going to our main compost pile. They were put in the back of a closet and forgotten, and I definitely don’t recommend doing that!

I look forward to vermicomposting again one day, not for the soil, but for the vermicompost tea. This method of composting is definitely for you if you aren’t worried about producing large amounts of soil, have children and want an educational and eco-friendly project to do, or if you’ve been looking for a great, organic fertilizer for your plants. You can find DIY setups that fit under your sink or buy a stackable compost bin to put in your garage, laundry room, etc.
***NOTE: Red wigglers do require a small amount of care and have min/max temperature requirements. Please be informed before investing money into your wiggling friends.***


The method I’m currently using and will continue to use for the rest of my composting life. Hot composting is where the microbial activity within the compost pile is at its optimum level, therefore decomposing the material within your pile at a faster rate and resulting in soil more quickly. You can add diseased plants and weed seeds to your hot compost pile because your pile will be heating up to 120º-170º (hopefully). There are five major factors to hot composting; let’s make like our compost pile and break it down.

    To start, you want your pile far enough from your house in case you attract unwanted guests (raccoons, rodents, the neighbors’ hound dog) and smells when you’re first starting out.  But you want it close enough to the house that you don’t have to break your back lugging your scrap bucket to the farthest point of your yard. You also want your pile on higher ground to prevent any kind of flooding from hard rains. (You want your pile to be moist, but not soaked.) Last, you want your pile in a sunny spot because shade can aid in cooling that hot thing down and we don’t want that, friends. My compost bin is in the middle point of our yard near the majority of my gardens. This part requires a little long-term planning but I know you’re capable of getting the job done!
  2. C: N RATIO
    The C: N ratio is 30 parts carbon (browns) to 1 part nitrogen (greens). Now, you can drive yourself nearly nuts if you try to obsess over this ratio. I know because I did. I would ask myself “Will I ever be able to do this!? How the heck do I know if my pile is the right ratio?” Well, the first answer is YES, you will definitely be able to do this, and the second answer is heat. That was far too vague and confusing for me as a beginner, so here’s what I did and still do: I slowly fill up a 5 gallon bucket with my scraps from the kitchen (green material) and every time I empty my bucket on my pile I then fill the empty bucket up with leaves or dead straw (brown material) 3-4 times and empty it on my compost pile, too. I understand this math doesn’t make sense, but what I want you to understand is that when I started doing this my compost pile got hot for the first time ever. Now every time I empty a bucket I make a small indentation in the center of my pile, add my greens, and cover it with my browns. I also keep a long stick stuck in the middle of my pile and pull it out every now and then to make sure my pile is still hot.
    Just as your healthy microbes need food to “eat,” they also need water. You don’t want to soak your compost pile; you want to moisten it like a squeezed sponge. If you live in an area that gets a steady supply of rain throughout the year then you shouldn’t have to add water to your pile. I live in West Central Florida and we get most of our rain in the summer in the form of torrential downpours that sometimes leave my ducks literally swimming in puddles. I keep my compost covered with a tarp so I have full control over the moisture level of the pile. Every time I add material, which is a few times a month, I lightly water everything in. Once my fresh brown material looks evenly damp I stop watering. The only time I ever water my pile between sessions of adding material is if I pull my “heat stick” out and it’s completely dry. If the end of the stick is nicely moist, I leave it be.
    I’ve heard disagreements on this point. Some people don’t believe you need to turn your pile and others swear by it. I’m going to preach to TURN IT UP Y’ALL! Every time I add my browns and greens, I turn my pile. First I turn my pile and then I add my new materials. Your microbes need food, they need water, and, so help me Hannah, they need air. Also, turning your pile assures that any material your undercover, microscopic workers haven’t yet found will be turned into the pile for closer reach.
  5. SIZE
    Finally, our fifth point. I hope I haven’t scared you away yet and I hope this last point doesn’t either. The four points we just went over mean nothing if your pile isn’t large enough. I know, I know – Are you kidding me? No kidding here, only compost. Your pile has to be at least 3 ft x 3 ft. Some people swear by a minimum of 4 ft x 4 ft! My pile is the latter and heats up wonderfully and is the perfect size for me to be able to stick a pitchfork in and turn it every now and then.


Dried Leaves/Foliage in General
Newspaper Clippings (Shredded)
Cardboard (Shredded)
Paper (No Gloss!)
Aged Hay (My favorite)
Chipped Wood
Dried Grass
Wood Ash
Coffee Filters
Peat Moss
Pine Needles (Shredded)
Sawdust (Only from untreated wood)
Paper Towels (Preferably not bleached)


Vegetable and Fruit Scraps (Minimal citrus)
Coffee Grounds
Tea Grounds
Manure from Herbivores (Horse, cow, goat, rabbit!)
Weeds (Remember, only weed seeds if HOT)
Plant Prunings
Fresh Grass Clippings
Old Flowers
Feathers (From culling your livestock)
Egg Shells


Meat and Dairy
Cat, Dog, and Human Manure
Glossy or Coated Paper
Synthetic Fertilizer
Large, Bulky Material


If you’re still here then congratulations to you! You’re ready to “hashtag make it hot”! Composting can be very intimidating and I’ll be the first to admit that I have a very long way to go. I learn something new every time I read about composting. Honestly, I plan to attempt every method of composting there is before I leave this sweet Earth.

My newest endeavor is deep litter composting. This method requires chicken manure and you can read a great post about it here. I’m on day 6 of this method and I hope that day 18 is just as great if I follow the directions!

*** UPDATE 1/19/2018: This method is WONDERFUL. I am so pleased with the outcome!***

Now go out, start that compost pile, and make it hot, Y’all! If you’re looking for the best vegetables to grow in your finished compost product, check out my post “Best Vegetables to Plant in Your Raised Garden Beds“!


  • An easy way to remember that the “browns” are carbon-rich materials is that they both have a “B”.
  • Can you guess what I’m going to say to remember that nitrogen-rich materials are “greens”? Yep, the “G”! Good job!
  • Meat and dairy will attract scavengers to your pile and we don’t want that.
  • Large, bulky items will slow your compost pile down. If you add a bag of shredded newspaper in one spot on your pile, it’ll become compacted over time, making it hard for your microbes to work and even harder to turn your pile. I know this from experience.
  • If you’re properly maintaining the 5 key points then there should be no scavengers sneaking into your pile at night to finish the steamed broccoli you swore you ate but found in the fridge a little too late, and your compost should be as steamy as your broccoli once was. Want to know about more odd things you can add to your pile? Check these out!
  • What Can You Add to the Compost Pile
  • 100 Things You Can Compost
Homestead Blog Hop Featured Badge

If you loved it, feel free to share it!
Share on Facebook
0Pin on Pinterest
0Tweet about this on Twitter
Email this to someone
Share on Reddit
0Share on StumbleUpon

2 Responses

  • We have a big compost pile which we turn over with the forks on the tractor. Plus I do trench composting which is super easy. Found you on Simple Homestead Blog Hop.

    • thegreenacrehomestead

      I’ve read about your trench composting and can’t wait to try it! Thanks for participating in the Simple Homestead Blog Hop, Candy!


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.